Jump to content


Photo

Bad to prune butterfly bush too early in Spring?


  • Please log in to reply
3 replies to this topic

#1 Digging in the Dirt

Digging in the Dirt

    Well Established

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 37 posts

Posted 30 April 2013 - 11:56 AM

Two years ago we bought our first butterfly bush.  The plants first winter was so mild that it basically overwintered.  We cut it back to about 18 inches from the ground and it grew to about 7 1/2 feet tall last year, and was just beautiful..

 

This year, most of the wood was toast with very little new growth on the plant.  So we cut the plant back to about 6 inches from the ground. 

 

However, someone just told us that we may have pruned our Butterfly Bush too early.  He said that pruning promotes growth, and if you prune it too early and the plant starts growing, we risk the chance of possibly killing the plant if we get another frost or two in early May?

 

Should we have waited a few more weeks to prune it?

 

Thanks.



#2 Steven Nikkila

Steven Nikkila

    Moderator

  • Moderators
  • 152 posts
  • LocationSE Michigan

Posted 12 May 2013 - 09:44 AM

We've been cutting back butterfly bush (Buddleia) to the ground (for over 30 years) at all different times in the spring (and fall for some) and have never lost one due to the timing of the pruning. I don't think yours will be effected. If a butterfly bush dies in spring it's almost always because of chronic drainage problems that incite root rot. Root rot is very evident when you take it out. If you're concerned during a frost you can cover it with some type of protection like we just wrote about this week. Here's the link to the article: http://gardenatoz.co...ost-protection/

 

If the person who recommended delaying the pruning has any knowledge of scientific trials can you ask them to give us a referral? We've looked and haven't found anything, so we fall back on having seen this species leaf out in every warm spell in winter getting killed back multiple times yet surviving.



#3 Janet Macunovich

Janet Macunovich

    Guru

  • Moderators
  • 429 posts

Posted 22 March 2016 - 10:13 AM

Just talking about this with one of the Detroit Zoo volunteer gardeners:

 

Here is a picture of the butterfly bush that we rescued from the zoo on our last zoo day back in 2014 -- when we were moving everything out of the way for the new Wolf exhibit.  I couldn't believe it when it overwintered last year, and the little stinker is already growing this year.

BuddleiaSproutsS.jpg

 

I know you said last week not to worry about covering the plants now that it's gotten cold again, but the low temperatures around my house are dropping into the lower 20's so I finally broke down and covered a few of my plants last night.

 

I haven't been gardening that long, but I do have to say that this is the first time I have had to protect plants from a frost during the winter.  Ok spring starts tomorrow, but it's still technically winter, right? :)

- G -

 

Here's what I sent back to G. I hope it prompts some tales of what butterfly bushes have done elsewhere and elsewhen (and just to put into perspective the invasive-plant warnings this may generate: in our region Buddleia is not generally invasive. We do see seedlings but not the plague seen in drier, longer-growing-season zones).

 

You're so right. It was still technically winter when you emailed. And in practical terms it may be winter yet again hereabouts, a few more days here and there!

 

I think your plants would have been fine. Although many started to grow in the warmth a while back, that growth arrested. And it rained, so there was moisture in the soil, so it is more of a heat sink than before. The plants didn't extend themselves out of the safety zone. They are close enough to the ground that the ground protects them. So try not to worry in what's to come!

 

Butterfly bushes, now. Buddleia davidii. They are tough. They grow in every break in the weather. Even in January I've seen them start to grow like this, like it's spring, only to get that growth killed back. They can put up with a ton of kill-backs, so long as they are where the soil's well drained. (So many times we've told people who said "I cut it and I killed it" that you cannot kill a buddleia by cutting it. If you cut it in spring and it did not grow back, it was dying or dead before you touched it, of poor drainage during winter. They cannot handle slow drainage while they're dormant.) Since yours made it through one winter in its current place already, it must be decently drained there.

 

If you believe in psychologically protecting plants (like me talking to things as I transplant them, encouraging them with descriptions of how good they're going to have it, and assurances that I'll let them stay put in that new place, etc.), here's another tactic. Tell it how lucky it is to be in your garden. Tell it if it was in my garden, very shortly now when I could get out to work there it would be faced with me saying to it, "Nice new leaves! But it's time for your annual cut, anyway, little bush." I'd say that then I'd whack it back to an inch high. Tell that to your plant and it might reach 12' in gratitude...

Janet



#4 Janet Macunovich

Janet Macunovich

    Guru

  • Moderators
  • 429 posts

Posted 22 March 2016 - 10:30 AM

Maybe you don't have to talk to your buddleia. Just show it this photo, of last May when I found a not-cut-all-the-way butterfly bush in a client's garden.

BuddleiaStubsOutN8117N8043s.jpg

It tells two tales. One, even if you cut the sprouting wood off, as my client did, the shrub is going to grow back. And two, if you keep leaving stubs and the bush keeps growing back from below those cuts, you're going to end up over years with a thicket of dead wood that's very difficult to work in.

 

Oh! It tells THREE stories. 3: How fast buddleia grows.  I just noticed how several of the new shoots had elongated, by the second photo and thought perhaps I took that one a day after the first. No. The photo on the left in the composite was taken  just 3 hours before the right-side shot.

 

Cut more, cut lower, to get a butterfly bush consisting entirely of graceful branches in fountain-spray arrangement, each minimally branched and beginning to bloom a bit later than if not pruned.






0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users